The wrong diagnosis can cure you

Authors

  • Mark Fedyk University of California, Davis, US

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.4454/mefisto.10-1.1651

Keywords:

Diagnosis, Jurisdictional Risk, Clinical Institutions, Clinical Workflows

Abstract

This paper challenges the traditional philosophical view of diagnoses as purely descriptive categorizations of pathophysiology, arguing instead that their primary function is to manage a patient's "jurisdictional risk" within complex healthcare systems. Jurisdictional risk is defined as the danger of a patient's condition remaining administratively invalid or illegible, which can result in patients becoming stranded between clinical jurisdictions and consequently unable to receive necessary care. By analyzing real clinical scenarios, the paper argues that an effective diagnosis acts as an essential tool for administrative routing. The diagnosis serves to reconcile the patient’s biological, social, and political characteristics with the various (i.e. political, financial, epistemological) norms of institutional where the patient is seeking care.  Consequently, a technically vague or strictly "wrong" diagnosis can be a cause of curative interventions, if it successfully reconciles these the structure of the patient's illness with the structure of the institutions various norms.  Ultimately, curing a patient requires more than describing biological dysfunction; it requires aligning the patient's condition with the political architecture of the hospitals and other clinical spaces, implying that an effective diagnosis is a synthesis of both astute physiological and political judgment.

Published

2026-11-12

Issue

Section

Focus